Simplify Command classes.

tools/testing/dart/command_output.dart

+// Copyright (c) 2017, the Dart project authors.  Please see the AUTHORS file
+// for details. All rights reserved. Use of this source code is governed by a
+// BSD-style license that can be found in the LICENSE file.
+
+import 'dart:convert';
+// We need to use the 'io' prefix here, otherwise io.exitCode will shadow
+// CommandOutput.exitCode in subclasses of CommandOutput.
+import 'dart:io' as io;
+
+import 'browser_controller.dart';
+import 'command.dart';
+import 'configuration.dart';
+import 'expectation.dart';
+import 'test_runner.dart';
+import 'utils.dart';
+
+/**
+ * CommandOutput records the output of a completed command: the process's exit
+ * code, the standard output and standard error, whether the process timed out,
+ * and the time the process took to run.  It does not contain a pointer to the
+ * [TestCase] this is the output of, so some functions require the test case
+ * to be passed as an argument.
+ */
+abstract class CommandOutput {
+  Command get command;
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase);
+
+  bool get hasCrashed;
+
+  bool get hasTimedOut;
+
+  bool didFail(TestCase testCase);
+
+  bool hasFailed(TestCase testCase);
+
+  bool get canRunDependendCommands;
+
+  bool get successful; // otherwise we might to retry running
+
+  Duration get time;
+
+  int get exitCode;
+
+  int get pid;
+
+  List<int> get stdout;
+
+  List<int> get stderr;
+
+  List<String> get diagnostics;
+
+  bool get compilationSkipped;
+}
+
+class CommandOutputImpl extends UniqueObject implements CommandOutput {
+  Command command;
+  int exitCode;
+
+  bool timedOut;
+  List<int> stdout;
+  List<int> stderr;
+  Duration time;
+  List<String> diagnostics;
+  bool compilationSkipped;
+  int pid;
+
+  /**
+   * A flag to indicate we have already printed a warning about ignoring the VM
+   * crash, to limit the amount of output produced per test.
+   */
+  bool alreadyPrintedWarning = false;
+
+  CommandOutputImpl(
+      Command this.command,
+      int this.exitCode,
+      bool this.timedOut,
+      List<int> this.stdout,
+      List<int> this.stderr,
+      Duration this.time,
+      bool this.compilationSkipped,
+      int this.pid) {
+    diagnostics = [];
+  }
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasFailed(testCase)) return Expectation.fail;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+    return Expectation.pass;
+  }
+
+  bool get hasCrashed {
+    // dart2js exits with code 253 in case of unhandled exceptions.
+    // The dart binary exits with code 253 in case of an API error such
+    // as an invalid snapshot file.
+    // In either case an exit code of 253 is considered a crash.
+    if (exitCode == 253) return true;
+    if (io.Platform.operatingSystem == 'windows') {
+      // The VM uses std::abort to terminate on asserts.
+      // std::abort terminates with exit code 3 on Windows.
+      if (exitCode == 3 || exitCode == CRASHING_BROWSER_EXITCODE) {
+        return !timedOut;
+      }
+      // If a program receives an uncaught system exception, the program
+      // terminates with the exception code as exit code.
+      // The 0x3FFFFF00 mask here tries to determine if an exception indicates
+      // a crash of the program.
+      // System exception codes can be found in 'winnt.h', for example
+      // "#define STATUS_ACCESS_VIOLATION  ((DWORD) 0xC0000005)"
+      return (!timedOut && (exitCode < 0) && ((0x3FFFFF00 & exitCode) == 0));
+    }
+    return !timedOut && ((exitCode < 0));
+  }
+
+  bool get hasTimedOut => timedOut;
+
+  bool didFail(TestCase testCase) {
+    return (exitCode != 0 && !hasCrashed);
+  }
+
+  bool get canRunDependendCommands {
+    // FIXME(kustermann): We may need to change this
+    return !hasTimedOut && exitCode == 0;
+  }
+
+  bool get successful {
+    // FIXME(kustermann): We may need to change this
+    return !hasTimedOut && exitCode == 0;
+  }
+
+  // Reverse result of a negative test.
+  bool hasFailed(TestCase testCase) {
+    return testCase.isNegative ? !didFail(testCase) : didFail(testCase);
+  }
+
+  bool get hasNonUtf8 => exitCode == NON_UTF_FAKE_EXITCODE;
+
+  Expectation _negateOutcomeIfNegativeTest(
+      Expectation outcome, bool isNegative) {
+    if (!isNegative) return outcome;
+    if (outcome == Expectation.ignore) return outcome;
+    if (outcome.canBeOutcomeOf(Expectation.fail)) {
+      return Expectation.pass;
+    }
+    return Expectation.fail;
+  }
+}
+
+class BrowserCommandOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl {

[Bill Hesse, 2017/06/15 12:08:40]

I just renamed BrowserCommandOutputImpl to ContentShellCommandOutputImpl in a
different CL that landed.

[Bob Nystrom, 2017/06/15 21:19:29]

Yup, I saw that when I merged. Renamed it here too.

+  // Although tests are reported as passing, content shell sometimes exits with
+  // a nonzero exitcode which makes our dartium builders extremely falky.
+  // See: http://dartbug.com/15139.
+  // TODO(rnystrom): Is this still needed? The underlying bug is closed.
+  static int WHITELISTED_CONTENTSHELL_EXITCODE = -1073740022;
+  static bool isWindows = io.Platform.operatingSystem == 'windows';
+  static bool _failedBecauseOfFlakyInfrastructure(
+      Command command, bool timedOut, List<int> stderrBytes) {
+    // If the browser test failed, it may have been because content shell
+    // and the virtual framebuffer X server didn't hook up, or it crashed with
+    // a core dump. Sometimes content shell crashes after it has set the stdout
+    // to PASS, so we have to do this check first.
+    // Content shell also fails with a broken pipe message: Issue 26739
+    var zygoteCrash =
+        new RegExp(r"ERROR:zygote_linux\.cc\(\d+\)] write: Broken pipe");
+    var stderr = decodeUtf8(stderrBytes);
+    // TODO(7564): See http://dartbug.com/7564
+    // This may not be happening anymore.  Test by removing this suppression.
+    if (stderr.contains(MESSAGE_CANNOT_OPEN_DISPLAY) ||
+        stderr.contains(MESSAGE_FAILED_TO_RUN_COMMAND)) {
+      DebugLogger.warning(
+          "Warning: Failure because of missing XDisplay. Test ignored");
+      return true;
+    }
+    // TODO(26739): See http://dartbug.com/26739
+    if (zygoteCrash.hasMatch(stderr)) {
+      DebugLogger.warning("Warning: Failure because of content_shell "
+          "zygote crash. Test ignored");
+      return true;
+    }
+    // TODO(28955): See http://dartbug.com/28955
+    if (timedOut &&
+        command is BrowserTestCommand &&
+        command.browser == Runtime.ie11) {
+      DebugLogger.warning("Timeout of ie11 on test page ${command.url}");
+      return true;
+    }
+    return false;
+  }
+
+  bool _infraFailure;
+
+  BrowserCommandOutputImpl(
+      Command command,
+      int exitCode,
+      bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout,
+      List<int> stderr,
+      Duration time,
+      bool compilationSkipped)
+      : _infraFailure =
+            _failedBecauseOfFlakyInfrastructure(command, timedOut, stderr),
+        super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time,
+            compilationSkipped, 0);
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    if (_infraFailure) {
+      return Expectation.ignore;
+    }
+
+    // Handle crashes and timeouts first
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    var outcome = _getOutcome();
+
+    if (testCase.hasRuntimeError) {
+      if (!outcome.canBeOutcomeOf(Expectation.runtimeError)) {
+        return Expectation.missingRuntimeError;
+      }
+    }
+    if (testCase.isNegative) {
+      if (outcome.canBeOutcomeOf(Expectation.fail)) return Expectation.pass;
+      return Expectation.fail;
+    }
+    return outcome;
+  }
+
+  bool get successful => canRunDependendCommands;
+
+  bool get canRunDependendCommands {
+    // We cannot rely on the exit code of content_shell as a method to
+    // determine if we were successful or not.
+    return super.canRunDependendCommands && !didFail(null);
+  }
+
+  bool get hasCrashed {
+    return super.hasCrashed || _rendererCrashed;
+  }
+
+  Expectation _getOutcome() {
+    if (_browserTestFailure) {
+      return Expectation.runtimeError;
+    }
+    return Expectation.pass;
+  }
+
+  bool get _rendererCrashed =>
+      decodeUtf8(super.stdout).contains("#CRASHED - rendere");
+
+  bool get _browserTestFailure {
+    // Browser tests fail unless stdout contains
+    // 'Content-Type: text/plain' followed by 'PASS'.
+    bool hasContentType = false;
+    var stdoutLines = decodeUtf8(super.stdout).split("\n");
+    var containsFail = false;
+    var containsPass = false;
+    for (String line in stdoutLines) {
+      switch (line) {
+        case 'Content-Type: text/plain':
+          hasContentType = true;
+          break;
+        case 'FAIL':
+          if (hasContentType) {
+            containsFail = true;
+          }
+          break;
+        case 'PASS':
+          if (hasContentType) {
+            containsPass = true;
+          }
+          break;
+      }
+    }
+    if (hasContentType) {
+      if (containsFail && containsPass) {
+        DebugLogger.warning("Test had 'FAIL' and 'PASS' in stdout. ($command)");
+      }
+      if (!containsFail && !containsPass) {
+        DebugLogger.warning("Test had neither 'FAIL' nor 'PASS' in stdout. "
+            "($command)");
+        return true;
+      }
+      if (containsFail) {
+        return true;
+      }
+      assert(containsPass);
+      if (exitCode != 0) {
+        var message = "All tests passed, but exitCode != 0. "
+            "Actual exitcode: $exitCode. "
+            "($command)";
+        DebugLogger.warning(message);
+        diagnostics.add(message);
+      }
+      return (!hasCrashed &&
+          exitCode != 0 &&
+          (!isWindows || exitCode != WHITELISTED_CONTENTSHELL_EXITCODE));
+    }
+    DebugLogger.warning("Couldn't find 'Content-Type: text/plain' in output. "
+        "($command).");
+    return true;
+  }
+}
+
+class HTMLBrowserCommandOutputImpl extends BrowserCommandOutputImpl {

[Bill Hesse, 2017/06/15 12:08:40]

I think this class may not be used any more.  Can you find a configuration that
will reach this?  Issue filed https://github.com/dart-lang/sdk/issues/29869

[Bob Nystrom, 2017/06/15 21:19:29]

It doesn't seem to be used, but the corresponding BrowserTestCommand does get
constructed. It just doesn't seem to make it's way to createCommandOutput() as
far as I can tell. But I'm not super confident about that, so I'll leave it
alone for now.

+  HTMLBrowserCommandOutputImpl(
+      Command command,
+      int exitCode,
+      bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout,
+      List<int> stderr,
+      Duration time,
+      bool compilationSkipped)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time,
+            compilationSkipped);
+
+  bool didFail(TestCase testCase) {
+    return _getOutcome() != Expectation.pass;
+  }
+
+  bool get _browserTestFailure {
+    // We should not need to convert back and forward.
+    var output = decodeUtf8(super.stdout);
+    if (output.contains("FAIL")) return true;
+    return !output.contains("PASS");
+  }
+}
+
+class BrowserTestJsonResult {
+  static const ALLOWED_TYPES = const [
+    'sync_exception',
+    'window_onerror',
+    'script_onerror',
+    'window_compilationerror',
+    'print',
+    'message_received',
+    'dom',
+    'debug'
+  ];
+
+  final Expectation outcome;
+  final String htmlDom;
+  final List<dynamic> events;
+
+  BrowserTestJsonResult(this.outcome, this.htmlDom, this.events);
+
+  static BrowserTestJsonResult parseFromString(String content) {
+    void validate(String assertion, bool value) {
+      if (!value) {
+        throw "InvalidFormat sent from browser driving page: $assertion:\n\n"
+            "$content";
+      }
+    }
+
+    try {
+      var events = JSON.decode(content);
+      if (events != null) {
+        validate("Message must be a List", events is List);
+
+        var messagesByType = <String, List<String>>{};
+        ALLOWED_TYPES.forEach((type) => messagesByType[type] = <String>[]);
+
+        for (var entry in events) {
+          validate("An entry must be a Map", entry is Map);
+
+          var type = entry['type'];
+          var value = entry['value'] as String;
+          var timestamp = entry['timestamp'];
+
+          validate("'type' of an entry must be a String", type is String);
+          validate("'type' has to be in $ALLOWED_TYPES.",
+              ALLOWED_TYPES.contains(type));
+          validate(
+              "'timestamp' of an entry must be a number", timestamp is num);
+
+          messagesByType[type].add(value);
+        }
+        validate("The message must have exactly one 'dom' entry.",
+            messagesByType['dom'].length == 1);
+
+        var dom = messagesByType['dom'][0];
+        if (dom.endsWith('\n')) {
+          dom = '$dom\n';
+        }
+
+        return new BrowserTestJsonResult(
+            _getOutcome(messagesByType), dom, events as List<dynamic>);
+      }
+    } catch (error) {
+      // If something goes wrong, we know the content was not in the correct
+      // JSON format. So we can't parse it.
+      // The caller is responsible for falling back to the old way of
+      // determining if a test failed.
+    }
+
+    return null;
+  }
+
+  static Expectation _getOutcome(Map<String, List<String>> messagesByType) {
+    occured(String type) => messagesByType[type].length > 0;
+    searchForMsg(List<String> types, String message) {
+      return types.any((type) => messagesByType[type].contains(message));
+    }
+
+    // FIXME(kustermann,ricow): I think this functionality doesn't work in
+    // test_controller.js: So far I haven't seen anything being reported on
+    // "window.compilationerror"
+    if (occured('window_compilationerror')) {
+      return Expectation.compileTimeError;
+    }
+
+    if (occured('sync_exception') ||
+        occured('window_onerror') ||
+        occured('script_onerror')) {
+      return Expectation.runtimeError;
+    }
+
+    if (messagesByType['dom'][0].contains('FAIL')) {
+      return Expectation.runtimeError;
+    }
+
+    // We search for these messages in 'print' and 'message_received' because
+    // the unittest implementation posts these messages using
+    // "window.postMessage()" instead of the normal "print()" them.
+
+    var isAsyncTest = searchForMsg(
+        ['print', 'message_received'], 'unittest-suite-wait-for-done');
+    var isAsyncSuccess =
+        searchForMsg(['print', 'message_received'], 'unittest-suite-success') ||
+            searchForMsg(['print', 'message_received'], 'unittest-suite-done');
+
+    if (isAsyncTest) {
+      if (isAsyncSuccess) {
+        return Expectation.pass;
+      }
+      return Expectation.runtimeError;
+    }
+
+    var mainStarted =
+        searchForMsg(['print', 'message_received'], 'dart-calling-main');
+    var mainDone =
+        searchForMsg(['print', 'message_received'], 'dart-main-done');
+
+    if (mainStarted && mainDone) {
+      return Expectation.pass;
+    }
+    return Expectation.fail;
+  }
+}
+
+class BrowserControllerTestOutcome extends CommandOutputImpl

[Bill Hesse, 2017/06/15 12:08:40]

This really should be named like the others, as
BrowserControllerCommandOutputImpl (or even BrowserCommandOutputImpl, since that
name is freed by my rename of the existing class).

[Bob Nystrom, 2017/06/15 21:19:29]

Done.

+    with UnittestSuiteMessagesMixin {
+  BrowserTestOutput _result;
+  Expectation _rawOutcome;
+
+  factory BrowserControllerTestOutcome(
+      Command command, BrowserTestOutput result) {
+    String indent(String string, int numSpaces) {
+      var spaces = new List.filled(numSpaces, ' ').join('');
+      return string
+          .replaceAll('\r\n', '\n')
+          .split('\n')
+          .map((line) => "$spaces$line")
+          .join('\n');
+    }
+
+    String stdout = "";
+    String stderr = "";
+    Expectation outcome;
+
+    var parsedResult =
+        BrowserTestJsonResult.parseFromString(result.lastKnownMessage);
+    if (parsedResult != null) {
+      outcome = parsedResult.outcome;
+    } else {
+      // Old way of determining whether a test failed or passed.
+      if (result.lastKnownMessage.contains("FAIL")) {
+        outcome = Expectation.runtimeError;
+      } else if (result.lastKnownMessage.contains("PASS")) {
+        outcome = Expectation.pass;
+      } else {
+        outcome = Expectation.runtimeError;
+      }
+    }
+
+    if (result.didTimeout) {
+      if (result.delayUntilTestStarted != null) {
+        stderr = "This test timed out. The delay until the test actually "
+            "started was: ${result.delayUntilTestStarted}.";
+      } else {
+        stderr = "This test has not notified test.py that it started running.";
+      }
+    }
+
+    if (parsedResult != null) {
+      stdout = "events:\n${indent(prettifyJson(parsedResult.events), 2)}\n\n";
+    } else {
+      stdout = "message:\n${indent(result.lastKnownMessage, 2)}\n\n";
+    }
+
+    stderr = '$stderr\n\n'
+        'BrowserOutput while running the test (* EXPERIMENTAL *):\n'
+        'BrowserOutput.stdout:\n'
+        '${indent(result.browserOutput.stdout.toString(), 2)}\n'
+        'BrowserOutput.stderr:\n'
+        '${indent(result.browserOutput.stderr.toString(), 2)}\n'
+        '\n';
+    return new BrowserControllerTestOutcome._internal(
+        command, result, outcome, encodeUtf8(stdout), encodeUtf8(stderr));
+  }
+
+  BrowserControllerTestOutcome._internal(
+      Command command,
+      BrowserTestOutput result,
+      this._rawOutcome,
+      List<int> stdout,
+      List<int> stderr)
+      : super(command, 0, result.didTimeout, stdout, stderr, result.duration,
+            false, 0) {
+    _result = result;
+  }
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    // Handle timeouts first
+    if (_result.didTimeout) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    // Multitests are handled specially
+    if (testCase.hasRuntimeError) {
+      if (_rawOutcome == Expectation.runtimeError) return Expectation.pass;
+      return Expectation.missingRuntimeError;
+    }
+
+    return _negateOutcomeIfNegativeTest(_rawOutcome, testCase.isNegative);
+  }
+}
+
+class AnalysisCommandOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl {
+  // An error line has 8 fields that look like:
+  // ERROR|COMPILER|MISSING_SOURCE|file:/tmp/t.dart|15|1|24|Missing source.
+  final int ERROR_LEVEL = 0;
+  final int ERROR_TYPE = 1;
+  final int FILENAME = 3;
+  final int FORMATTED_ERROR = 7;
+
+  AnalysisCommandOutputImpl(
+      Command command,
+      int exitCode,
+      bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout,
+      List<int> stderr,
+      Duration time,
+      bool compilationSkipped)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time,
+            compilationSkipped, 0);
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    // TODO(kustermann): If we run the analyzer not in batch mode, make sure
+    // that command.exitCodes matches 2 (errors), 1 (warnings), 0 (no warnings,
+    // no errors)
+
+    // Handle crashes and timeouts first
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    // Get the errors/warnings from the analyzer
+    List<String> errors = [];
+    List<String> warnings = [];
+    parseAnalyzerOutput(errors, warnings);
+
+    // Handle errors / missing errors
+    if (testCase.expectCompileError) {
+      if (errors.length > 0) {
+        return Expectation.pass;
+      }
+      return Expectation.missingCompileTimeError;
+    }
+    if (errors.length > 0) {
+      return Expectation.compileTimeError;
+    }
+
+    // Handle static warnings / missing static warnings
+    if (testCase.hasStaticWarning) {
+      if (warnings.length > 0) {
+        return Expectation.pass;
+      }
+      return Expectation.missingStaticWarning;
+    }
+    if (warnings.length > 0) {
+      return Expectation.staticWarning;
+    }
+
+    assert(errors.length == 0 && warnings.length == 0);
+    assert(!testCase.hasCompileError && !testCase.hasStaticWarning);
+    return Expectation.pass;
+  }
+
+  void parseAnalyzerOutput(List<String> outErrors, List<String> outWarnings) {
+    // Parse a line delimited by the | character using \ as an escape character
+    // like:  FOO|BAR|FOO\|BAR|FOO\\BAZ as 4 fields: FOO BAR FOO|BAR FOO\BAZ
+    List<String> splitMachineError(String line) {
+      StringBuffer field = new StringBuffer();
+      List<String> result = [];
+      bool escaped = false;
+      for (var i = 0; i < line.length; i++) {
+        var c = line[i];
+        if (!escaped && c == '\\') {
+          escaped = true;
+          continue;
+        }
+        escaped = false;
+        if (c == '|') {
+          result.add(field.toString());
+          field = new StringBuffer();
+          continue;
+        }
+        field.write(c);
+      }
+      result.add(field.toString());
+      return result;
+    }
+
+    for (String line in decodeUtf8(super.stderr).split("\n")) {
+      if (line.length == 0) continue;
+      List<String> fields = splitMachineError(line);
+      // We only consider errors/warnings for files of interest.
+      if (fields.length > FORMATTED_ERROR) {
+        if (fields[ERROR_LEVEL] == 'ERROR') {
+          outErrors.add(fields[FORMATTED_ERROR]);
+        } else if (fields[ERROR_LEVEL] == 'WARNING') {
+          outWarnings.add(fields[FORMATTED_ERROR]);
+        }
+        // OK to Skip error output that doesn't match the machine format
+      }
+    }
+  }
+}
+
+class VmCommandOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl
+    with UnittestSuiteMessagesMixin {
+  static const DART_VM_EXITCODE_DFE_ERROR = 252;
+  static const DART_VM_EXITCODE_COMPILE_TIME_ERROR = 254;
+  static const DART_VM_EXITCODE_UNCAUGHT_EXCEPTION = 255;
+
+  VmCommandOutputImpl(Command command, int exitCode, bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout, List<int> stderr, Duration time, int pid)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, false, pid);
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    // Handle crashes and timeouts first
+    if (exitCode == DART_VM_EXITCODE_DFE_ERROR) return Expectation.dartkCrash;
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    // Multitests are handled specially
+    if (testCase.expectCompileError) {
+      if (exitCode == DART_VM_EXITCODE_COMPILE_TIME_ERROR) {
+        return Expectation.pass;
+      }
+      return Expectation.missingCompileTimeError;
+    }
+    if (testCase.hasRuntimeError) {
+      // TODO(kustermann): Do we consider a "runtimeError" only an uncaught
+      // exception or does any nonzero exit code fullfil this requirement?
+      if (exitCode != 0) {
+        return Expectation.pass;
+      }
+      return Expectation.missingRuntimeError;
+    }
+
+    // The actual outcome depends on the exitCode
+    Expectation outcome;
+    if (exitCode == DART_VM_EXITCODE_COMPILE_TIME_ERROR) {
+      outcome = Expectation.compileTimeError;
+    } else if (exitCode == DART_VM_EXITCODE_UNCAUGHT_EXCEPTION) {
+      outcome = Expectation.runtimeError;
+    } else if (exitCode != 0) {
+      // This is a general fail, in case we get an unknown nonzero exitcode.
+      outcome = Expectation.fail;
+    } else {
+      outcome = Expectation.pass;
+    }
+    outcome = _negateOutcomeIfIncompleteAsyncTest(outcome, decodeUtf8(stdout));
+    return _negateOutcomeIfNegativeTest(outcome, testCase.isNegative);
+  }
+}
+
+class CompilationCommandOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl {
+  static const DART2JS_EXITCODE_CRASH = 253;
+
+  CompilationCommandOutputImpl(
+      Command command,
+      int exitCode,
+      bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout,
+      List<int> stderr,
+      Duration time,
+      bool compilationSkipped)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time,
+            compilationSkipped, 0);
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    // Handle general crash/timeout detection.
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) {
+      bool isWindows = io.Platform.operatingSystem == 'windows';
+      bool isBrowserTestCase =
+          testCase.commands.any((command) => command is BrowserTestCommand);
+      // TODO(26060) Dart2js batch mode hangs on Windows under heavy load.
+      return (isWindows && isBrowserTestCase)
+          ? Expectation.ignore
+          : Expectation.timeout;
+    }
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    // Handle dart2js specific crash detection
+    if (exitCode == DART2JS_EXITCODE_CRASH ||
+        exitCode == VmCommandOutputImpl.DART_VM_EXITCODE_COMPILE_TIME_ERROR ||
+        exitCode == VmCommandOutputImpl.DART_VM_EXITCODE_UNCAUGHT_EXCEPTION) {
+      return Expectation.crash;
+    }
+
+    // Multitests are handled specially
+    if (testCase.expectCompileError) {
+      // Nonzero exit code of the compiler means compilation failed
+      // TODO(kustermann): Do we have a special exit code in that case???
+      if (exitCode != 0) {
+        return Expectation.pass;
+      }
+      return Expectation.missingCompileTimeError;
+    }
+
+    // TODO(kustermann): This is a hack, remove it
+    if (testCase.hasRuntimeError && testCase.commands.length > 1) {
+      // We expected to run the test, but we got an compile time error.
+      // If the compilation succeeded, we wouldn't be in here!
+      assert(exitCode != 0);
+      return Expectation.compileTimeError;
+    }
+
+    Expectation outcome =
+        exitCode == 0 ? Expectation.pass : Expectation.compileTimeError;
+    return _negateOutcomeIfNegativeTest(outcome, testCase.isNegative);
+  }
+}
+
+class KernelCompilationCommandOutputImpl extends CompilationCommandOutputImpl {
+  KernelCompilationCommandOutputImpl(
+      Command command,
+      int exitCode,
+      bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout,
+      List<int> stderr,
+      Duration time,
+      bool compilationSkipped)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time,
+            compilationSkipped);
+
+  bool get canRunDependendCommands {
+    // See [BatchRunnerProcess]: 0 means success, 1 means compile-time error.
+    // TODO(asgerf): When the frontend supports it, continue running even if
+    //   there were compile-time errors. See kernel_sdk issue #18.
+    return !hasCrashed && !timedOut && exitCode == 0;
+  }
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    Expectation result = super.result(testCase);
+    if (result.canBeOutcomeOf(Expectation.crash)) {
+      return Expectation.dartkCrash;
+    } else if (result.canBeOutcomeOf(Expectation.timeout)) {
+      return Expectation.dartkTimeout;
+    } else if (result.canBeOutcomeOf(Expectation.compileTimeError)) {
+      return Expectation.dartkCompileTimeError;
+    }
+    return result;
+  }
+
+  // If the compiler was able to produce a Kernel IR file we want to run the
+  // result on the Dart VM.  We therefore mark the [KernelCompilationCommand] as
+  // successful.
+  // => This ensures we test that the DartVM produces correct CompileTime errors
+  //    as it is supposed to for our test suites.
+  bool get successful => canRunDependendCommands;
+}
+
+class JsCommandlineOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl
+    with UnittestSuiteMessagesMixin {
+  JsCommandlineOutputImpl(Command command, int exitCode, bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout, List<int> stderr, Duration time)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, false, 0);
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    // Handle crashes and timeouts first
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    if (testCase.hasRuntimeError) {
+      if (exitCode != 0) return Expectation.pass;
+      return Expectation.missingRuntimeError;
+    }
+
+    var outcome = exitCode == 0 ? Expectation.pass : Expectation.runtimeError;
+    outcome = _negateOutcomeIfIncompleteAsyncTest(outcome, decodeUtf8(stdout));
+    return _negateOutcomeIfNegativeTest(outcome, testCase.isNegative);
+  }
+}
+
+class PubCommandOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl {
+  PubCommandOutputImpl(PubCommand command, int exitCode, bool timedOut,
+      List<int> stdout, List<int> stderr, Duration time)
+      : super(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, false, 0);
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) {
+    // Handle crashes and timeouts first
+    if (hasCrashed) return Expectation.crash;
+    if (hasTimedOut) return Expectation.timeout;
+    if (hasNonUtf8) return Expectation.nonUtf8Error;
+
+    if (exitCode == 0) {
+      return Expectation.pass;
+    } else if ((command as PubCommand).command == 'get') {
+      return Expectation.pubGetError;
+    } else {
+      return Expectation.fail;
+    }
+  }
+}
+
+class ScriptCommandOutputImpl extends CommandOutputImpl {
+  final Expectation _result;
+
+  ScriptCommandOutputImpl(ScriptCommand command, this._result,
+      String scriptExecutionInformation, Duration time)
+      : super(command, 0, false, [], [], time, false, 0) {
+    var lines = scriptExecutionInformation.split("\n");
+    diagnostics.addAll(lines);
+  }
+
+  Expectation result(TestCase testCase) => _result;
+
+  bool get canRunDependendCommands => _result == Expectation.pass;
+
+  bool get successful => _result == Expectation.pass;
+}
+
+CommandOutput createCommandOutput(Command command, int exitCode, bool timedOut,
+    List<int> stdout, List<int> stderr, Duration time, bool compilationSkipped,
+    [int pid = 0]) {
+  if (command is ContentShellCommand) {
+    return new BrowserCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, compilationSkipped);
+  } else if (command is BrowserTestCommand) {
+    return new HTMLBrowserCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, compilationSkipped);
+  } else if (command is AnalysisCommand) {
+    return new AnalysisCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, compilationSkipped);
+  } else if (command is VmCommand) {
+    return new VmCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, pid);
+  } else if (command is KernelCompilationCommand) {
+    return new KernelCompilationCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, compilationSkipped);
+  } else if (command is AdbPrecompilationCommand) {
+    return new VmCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, pid);
+  } else if (command is CompilationCommand) {
+    if (command.displayName == 'precompiler' ||
+        command.displayName == 'app_jit') {
+      return new VmCommandOutputImpl(
+          command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, pid);
+    }
+    return new CompilationCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time, compilationSkipped);
+  } else if (command is JSCommandlineCommand) {
+    return new JsCommandlineOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time);
+  } else if (command is PubCommand) {
+    return new PubCommandOutputImpl(
+        command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr, time);
+  }
+
+  return new CommandOutputImpl(command, exitCode, timedOut, stdout, stderr,
+      time, compilationSkipped, pid);
+}
+
+class UnittestSuiteMessagesMixin {
+  bool _isAsyncTest(String testOutput) {
+    return testOutput.contains("unittest-suite-wait-for-done");
+  }
+
+  bool _isAsyncTestSuccessful(String testOutput) {
+    return testOutput.contains("unittest-suite-success");
+  }
+
+  Expectation _negateOutcomeIfIncompleteAsyncTest(
+      Expectation outcome, String testOutput) {
+    // If this is an asynchronous test and the asynchronous operation didn't
+    // complete successfully, it's outcome is Expectation.FAIL.
+    // TODO: maybe we should introduce a AsyncIncomplete marker or so
+    if (outcome == Expectation.pass) {
+      if (_isAsyncTest(testOutput) && !_isAsyncTestSuccessful(testOutput)) {
+        return Expectation.fail;
+      }
+    }
+    return outcome;
+  }
+}