Add Om1 lowering with no optimizations

crosstest/test_arith_main.cpp

Index: crosstest/test_arith_main.cpp
diff --git a/crosstest/test_arith_main.cpp b/crosstest/test_arith_main.cpp
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c93972260e670fa91d855bec12da5ae9747b8cc0
--- /dev/null
+++ b/crosstest/test_arith_main.cpp
@@ -0,0 +1,246 @@
+// crosstest.py --test=test_arith.cpp --driver=test_arith_main.cpp
+// --prefix=Subzero_ --output=test_arith
+

[JF, 2014/05/01 00:16:55]

I think that this test could be partly evaluated at compile-time when built with
LTO. You probably want to make the access to Values be volatile, or create a
no-inline getter to Values, so that the compiler can't cleverly optimize the
test away.

[Jim Stichnoth, 2014/05/05 07:03:55]

Done.  I changed the arrays to be volatile (here and elsewhere).

+#include <stdio.h>
+#include <stdint.h>
+
+#include "test_arith.h"
+namespace Subzero_ {
+#include "test_arith.h"
+}

[JF, 2014/05/01 00:16:55]

Ew. That is quite ugly... and kind of clever. Could you explain it?

[Jim Stichnoth, 2014/05/05 07:03:55]

Done.

+
+int main(int argc, char **argv) {
+  static unsigned Values[] = { 0x0,        0x1,        0x7ffffffe, 0x7fffffff,
+                               0x80000000, 0x80000001, 0xfffffffe, 0xffffffff,
+                               0x7e,       0x7f,       0x80,       0x81,
+                               0xfe,       0xff,       0x100,      0x101,
+                               0x7ffe,     0x7fff,     0x8000,     0x8001,
+                               0xfffe,     0xffff,     0x10000,    0x10001, };
+  const static unsigned NumValues = sizeof(Values) / sizeof(*Values);

[JF, 2014/05/01 00:16:55]

size_t, same on loop bounds.

[Jim Stichnoth, 2014/05/05 07:03:55]

Done.

+
+  typedef uint8_t (*FuncType8)(uint8_t, uint8_t);
+  typedef int8_t (*FuncTypeS8)(int8_t, int8_t);
+  static struct {
+    const char *Name;
+    FuncType8 FuncLlc;
+    FuncType8 FuncSz;
+    bool DisallowIllegal; // for divide related tests

[JF, 2014/05/01 00:16:55]

Could you instead figure out that the test is illegal from its name? You already
check the value. You're also exercising undefined behavior with the shift by
larger than / equal to bitwidth.

[Jim Stichnoth, 2014/05/05 07:03:55]

The name is only meant for printing failing tests, so I don't think it's a good
idea to overload it to affect the testing.

Regarding undefined behavior - if practical, I would prefer Subzero to produce
the same results as llc even when the behavior is undefined, just to minimize
time tracking down "bugs" in broken tests.  But with that said, I'm changing the
name DisallowIllegal to indicate disallowing exceptions rather than arbitrary
undefined behavior.

+  } Func8[] = {
+      { "testAdd8", (FuncType8)testAdd, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testAdd },
+      { "testSub8", (FuncType8)testSub, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testSub },
+      { "testMul8", (FuncType8)testMul, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testMul },
+      { "testUdiv8", (FuncType8)testUdiv, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testUdiv, true },
+      { "testSdiv8",
+        (FuncType8)(FuncTypeS8)testSdiv,
+        (FuncType8)(FuncTypeS8)Subzero_::testSdiv,
+        true },
+      { "testUrem8", (FuncType8)testUrem, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testUrem, true },
+      { "testSrem8",
+        (FuncType8)(FuncTypeS8)testSrem,
+        (FuncType8)(FuncTypeS8)Subzero_::testSrem,
+        true },
+      { "testShl8", (FuncType8)testShl, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testShl },
+      { "testLshr8", (FuncType8)testLshr, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testLshr },
+      { "testAshr8", (FuncType8)(FuncTypeS8)testAshr,
+        (FuncType8)(FuncTypeS8)Subzero_::testAshr },
+      { "testAnd8", (FuncType8)testAnd, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testAnd },
+      { "testOr8", (FuncType8)testOr, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testOr },
+      { "testXor8", (FuncType8)testXor, (FuncType8)Subzero_::testXor },
+    };

[JF, 2014/05/01 00:16:55]

xmacros!!! It seems like the test declaration/definition/registration could all
be folded together, and it would be more readable and unlikely to diverge that
way.

[Jim Stichnoth, 2014/05/05 07:03:55]

Done.

+  const static unsigned NumFunc8 = sizeof(Func8) / sizeof(*Func8);
+
+  typedef uint16_t (*FuncType16)(uint16_t, uint16_t);
+  typedef int16_t (*FuncTypeS16)(int16_t, int16_t);
+  static struct {
+    const char *Name;
+    FuncType16 FuncLlc;
+    FuncType16 FuncSz;
+    bool DisallowIllegal; // on the second arg, for divide related tests
+  } Func16[] =
+        { { "testAdd16", (FuncType16)testAdd, (FuncType16)Subzero_::testAdd },
+          { "testSub16", (FuncType16)testSub, (FuncType16)Subzero_::testSub },
+          { "testMul16", (FuncType16)testMul, (FuncType16)Subzero_::testMul },
+          { "testUdiv16",                   (FuncType16)testUdiv,
+            (FuncType16)Subzero_::testUdiv, true },
+          { "testSdiv16",
+            (FuncType16)(FuncTypeS16)testSdiv,
+            (FuncType16)(FuncTypeS16)Subzero_::testSdiv,
+            true },
+          { "testUrem16",                   (FuncType16)testUrem,
+            (FuncType16)Subzero_::testUrem, true },
+          { "testSrem16",
+            (FuncType16)(FuncTypeS16)testSrem,
+            (FuncType16)(FuncTypeS16)Subzero_::testSrem,
+            true },
+          { "testShl16", (FuncType16)testShl, (FuncType16)Subzero_::testShl },
+          { "testLshr16", (FuncType16)testLshr,
+            (FuncType16)Subzero_::testLshr },
+          { "testAshr16", (FuncType16)(FuncTypeS16)testAshr,
+            (FuncType16)(FuncTypeS16)Subzero_::testAshr },
+          { "testAnd16", (FuncType16)testAnd, (FuncType16)Subzero_::testAnd },
+          { "testOr16", (FuncType16)testOr, (FuncType16)Subzero_::testOr },
+          { "testXor16", (FuncType16)testXor,
+            (FuncType16)Subzero_::testXor }, };
+  const static unsigned NumFunc16 = sizeof(Func16) / sizeof(*Func16);
+
+  typedef uint32_t (*FuncType32)(uint32_t, uint32_t);
+  typedef int32_t (*FuncTypeS32)(int32_t, int32_t);
+  static struct {
+    const char *Name;
+    FuncType32 FuncLlc;
+    FuncType32 FuncSz;
+    bool DisallowIllegal; // on the second arg, for divide related tests
+  } Func32[] =
+        { { "testAdd32", (FuncType32)testAdd, (FuncType32)Subzero_::testAdd },
+          { "testSub32", (FuncType32)testSub, (FuncType32)Subzero_::testSub },
+          { "testMul32", (FuncType32)testMul, (FuncType32)Subzero_::testMul },
+          { "testUdiv32",                   (FuncType32)testUdiv,
+            (FuncType32)Subzero_::testUdiv, true },
+          { "testSdiv32",
+            (FuncType32)(FuncTypeS32)testSdiv,
+            (FuncType32)(FuncTypeS32)Subzero_::testSdiv,
+            true },
+          { "testUrem32",                   (FuncType32)testUrem,
+            (FuncType32)Subzero_::testUrem, true },
+          { "testSrem32",
+            (FuncType32)(FuncTypeS32)testSrem,
+            (FuncType32)(FuncTypeS32)Subzero_::testSrem,
+            true },
+          { "testShl32", (FuncType32)testShl, (FuncType32)Subzero_::testShl },
+          { "testLshr32", (FuncType32)testLshr,
+            (FuncType32)Subzero_::testLshr },
+          { "testAshr32", (FuncType32)(FuncTypeS32)testAshr,
+            (FuncType32)(FuncTypeS32)Subzero_::testAshr },
+          { "testAnd32", (FuncType32)testAnd, (FuncType32)Subzero_::testAnd },
+          { "testOr32", (FuncType32)testOr, (FuncType32)Subzero_::testOr },
+          { "testXor32", (FuncType32)testXor,
+            (FuncType32)Subzero_::testXor }, };
+  const static unsigned NumFunc32 = sizeof(Func32) / sizeof(*Func32);
+
+  typedef uint64_t (*FuncType64)(uint64_t, uint64_t);
+  typedef int64_t (*FuncTypeS64)(int64_t, int64_t);
+  static struct {
+    const char *Name;
+    FuncType64 FuncLlc;
+    FuncType64 FuncSz;
+    bool DisallowIllegal; // on the second arg, for divide related tests
+  } Func64[] =
+        { { "testAdd64", (FuncType64)testAdd, (FuncType64)Subzero_::testAdd },
+          { "testSub64", (FuncType64)testSub, (FuncType64)Subzero_::testSub },
+          { "testMul64", (FuncType64)testMul, (FuncType64)Subzero_::testMul },
+          { "testUdiv64",                   (FuncType64)testUdiv,
+            (FuncType64)Subzero_::testUdiv, true },
+          { "testSdiv64",
+            (FuncType64)(FuncTypeS64)testSdiv,
+            (FuncType64)(FuncTypeS64)Subzero_::testSdiv,
+            true },
+          { "testUrem64",                   (FuncType64)testUrem,
+            (FuncType64)Subzero_::testUrem, true },
+          { "testSrem64",
+            (FuncType64)(FuncTypeS64)testSrem,
+            (FuncType64)(FuncTypeS64)Subzero_::testSrem,
+            true },
+          { "testShl64", (FuncType64)testShl, (FuncType64)Subzero_::testShl },
+          { "testLshr64", (FuncType64)testLshr,
+            (FuncType64)Subzero_::testLshr },
+          { "testAshr64", (FuncType64)(FuncTypeS64)testAshr,
+            (FuncType64)(FuncTypeS64)Subzero_::testAshr },
+          { "testAnd64", (FuncType64)testAnd, (FuncType64)Subzero_::testAnd },
+          { "testOr64", (FuncType64)testOr, (FuncType64)Subzero_::testOr },
+          { "testXor64", (FuncType64)testXor,
+            (FuncType64)Subzero_::testXor }, };
+  const static unsigned NumFunc64 = sizeof(Func64) / sizeof(*Func64);
+
+  unsigned TotalTests = 0;
+  unsigned Passes = 0;
+  unsigned Failures = 0;
+
+  for (unsigned f = 0; f < NumFunc8; ++f) {
+    for (unsigned i = 0; i < NumValues; ++i) {
+      for (unsigned j = 0; j < NumValues; ++j) {
+        if (Func8[f].DisallowIllegal && ((uint8_t)Values[j] == 0))
+          continue;
+        ++TotalTests;
+        uint8_t ResultSz = Func8[f].FuncSz(Values[i], Values[j]);
+        uint8_t ResultLlc = Func8[f].FuncLlc(Values[i], Values[j]);
+        if (ResultSz == ResultLlc) {
+          ++Passes;
+        } else {
+          ++Failures;
+          printf("%s(0x%08x, 0x%08x): sz=%d llc=%d\n", Func8[f].Name, Values[i],
+                 Values[j], ResultSz, ResultLlc);
+        }
+      }
+    }
+  }
+
+  for (unsigned f = 0; f < NumFunc16; ++f) {
+    for (unsigned i = 0; i < NumValues; ++i) {
+      for (unsigned j = 0; j < NumValues; ++j) {
+        if (Func16[f].DisallowIllegal && ((uint16_t)Values[j] == 0))
+          continue;
+        ++TotalTests;
+        uint16_t ResultSz = Func16[f].FuncSz(Values[i], Values[j]);
+        uint16_t ResultLlc = Func16[f].FuncLlc(Values[i], Values[j]);
+        if (ResultSz == ResultLlc) {
+          ++Passes;
+        } else {
+          ++Failures;
+          printf("%s(0x%08x, 0x%08x): sz=%d llc=%d\n", Func16[f].Name,
+                 Values[i], Values[j], ResultSz, ResultLlc);
+        }
+      }
+    }
+  }
+
+  for (unsigned f = 0; f < NumFunc32; ++f) {
+    for (unsigned i = 0; i < NumValues; ++i) {
+      for (unsigned j = 0; j < NumValues; ++j) {
+        if (Func32[f].DisallowIllegal && Values[j] == 0)
+          continue;
+        if (Func32[f].DisallowIllegal && Values[i] == 0x80000000 &&
+            Values[j] == 0xffffffff)
+          continue;
+        ++TotalTests;
+        uint32_t ResultSz = Func32[f].FuncSz(Values[i], Values[j]);
+        uint32_t ResultLlc = Func32[f].FuncLlc(Values[i], Values[j]);
+        if (ResultSz == ResultLlc) {
+          ++Passes;
+        } else {
+          ++Failures;
+          printf("%s(0x%08x, 0x%08x): sz=%d llc=%d\n", Func32[f].Name,
+                 Values[i], Values[j], ResultSz, ResultLlc);
+        }
+      }
+    }
+  }

[JF, 2014/05/01 00:16:55]

It seems like the 3 loops above are pretty much the same thing. Could you factor
it out?

[Jim Stichnoth, 2014/05/05 07:03:55]

Done.  BTW, after refactoring, I discovered that I neglected to add the FP
tests, so this is now added.

+
+  for (unsigned f = 0; f < NumFunc64; ++f) {
+    for (unsigned iLo = 0; iLo < NumValues; ++iLo) {
+      for (unsigned iHi = 0; iHi < NumValues; ++iHi) {
+        for (unsigned jLo = 0; jLo < NumValues; ++jLo) {
+          for (unsigned jHi = 0; jHi < NumValues; ++jHi) {
+            uint64_t Value1 = (((uint64_t)Values[iHi]) << 32) + Values[iLo];
+            uint64_t Value2 = (((uint64_t)Values[jHi]) << 32) + Values[jLo];
+
+            if (Func64[f].DisallowIllegal && Value2 == 0)
+              continue;
+            ++TotalTests;
+            uint64_t ResultSz = Func64[f].FuncSz(Value1, Value2);
+            uint64_t ResultLlc = Func64[f].FuncLlc(Value1, Value2);
+            if (ResultSz == ResultLlc) {
+              ++Passes;
+            } else {
+              ++Failures;
+              printf("%s(0x%016llx, 0x%016llx): sz=%llx llc=%llx\n",
+                     Func64[f].Name, Value1, Value2, ResultSz, ResultLlc);
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      }
+    }
+  }
+
+  printf("TotalTests=%u Passes=%u Failures=%u\n", TotalTests, Passes, Failures);
+  return Failures;
+}