Failing DCHECK exposing eval origin bug

test/mjsunit/harmony/debug-async-liveedit.js

Index: test/mjsunit/harmony/debug-async-liveedit.js
diff --git a/test/mjsunit/es6/generators-debug-liveedit.js b/test/mjsunit/harmony/debug-async-liveedit.js
similarity index 52%
copy from test/mjsunit/es6/generators-debug-liveedit.js
copy to test/mjsunit/harmony/debug-async-liveedit.js
index 987a42c41cd94b986e741d6be18bbaa11f7be452..4b69f267f3bbf4d79ecbc4de0c6b501f63bfd9b5 100644
--- a/test/mjsunit/es6/generators-debug-liveedit.js
+++ b/test/mjsunit/harmony/debug-async-liveedit.js
@@ -1,7 +1,8 @@
-// Copyright 2014 the V8 project authors. All rights reserved.
+// Copyright 2016 the V8 project authors. All rights reserved.
 // Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
 // found in the LICENSE file.
 
+// Flags: --harmony-async-await
 // Flags: --expose-debug-as debug --allow-natives-syntax
 
 var Debug = debug.Debug;
@@ -9,18 +10,27 @@ var LiveEdit = Debug.LiveEdit;
 
 unique_id = 0;
 
-var Generator = (function*(){}).constructor;
+var AsyncFunction = (async function(){}).constructor;
 
-function assertIteratorResult(value, done, result) {
-  assertEquals({value: value, done: done}, result);
+function assertPromiseValue(value, promise) {
+  promise.then(resolve => {
+    went = true;
+    if (resolve !== value) {
+      print(`expected ${value} found ${resolve}`);
+      quit(1);
+    }
+  }, reject => {
+    print(`rejected ${reject}`);
+    quit(1);
+  });
 }
 
-function MakeGenerator() {
+function MakeAsyncFunction() {
   // Prevents eval script caching.
   unique_id++;
-  return Generator('callback',
+  return AsyncFunction('callback',
       "/* " + unique_id + "*/\n" +
-      "yield callback();\n" +
+      "await callback();\n" +
       "return 'Cat';\n");
 }
 
@@ -35,11 +45,10 @@ function MakeFunction() {
 
 // First, try MakeGenerator with no perturbations.
 (function(){
-  var generator = MakeGenerator();
+  var asyncfn = MakeAsyncFunction();
   function callback() {};
-  var iter = generator(callback);
-  assertIteratorResult(undefined, false, iter.next());
-  assertIteratorResult("Cat", true, iter.next());
+  var promise = asyncfn(callback);
+  assertPromiseValue('Cat', promise);
 })();
 
 function patch(fun, from, to) {
@@ -47,6 +56,7 @@ function patch(fun, from, to) {
     var log = new Array();
     var script = Debug.findScript(fun);
     var pos = script.source.indexOf(from);
+    print(`pos ${pos}`);
     try {
       LiveEdit.TestApi.ApplySingleChunkPatch(script, pos, from.length, to,
                                              log);
@@ -57,40 +67,41 @@ function patch(fun, from, to) {
   %ExecuteInDebugContext(debug);
 }
 
-// Try to edit a MakeGenerator while it's running, then again while it's
+// Try to edit a MakeAsyncFunction while it's running, then again while it's
 // stopped.
 (function(){
-  var generator = MakeGenerator();
+  var asyncfn = MakeAsyncFunction();
 
-  var gen_patch_attempted = false;
-  function attempt_gen_patch() {
-    assertFalse(gen_patch_attempted);
-    gen_patch_attempted = true;
-    assertThrows(function() { patch(generator, "'Cat'", "'Capybara'") },
+  var patch_attempted = false;
+  function attempt_patch() {
+    assertFalse(patch_attempted);
+    patch_attempted = true;
+    assertThrows(function() { patch(asyncfn, "'Cat'", "'Capybara'") },
                  LiveEdit.Failure);
   };
-  var iter = generator(attempt_gen_patch);
-  assertIteratorResult(undefined, false, iter.next());
-  // Patch should not succeed because there is a live generator activation on
-  // the stack.
-  assertIteratorResult("Cat", true, iter.next());
-  assertTrue(gen_patch_attempted);
+  var promise = asyncfn(attempt_patch);
+  // Patch should not succeed because there is a live async function activation
+  // on the stack.
+  assertPromiseValue("Cat", promise);
+  assertTrue(patch_attempted);
+
+  %RunMicrotasks();
 
   // At this point one iterator is live, but closed, so the patch will succeed.
-  patch(generator, "'Cat'", "'Capybara'");
-  iter = generator(function(){});
-  assertIteratorResult(undefined, false, iter.next());
+  patch(asyncfn, "'Cat'", "'Capybara'");
+  promise = asyncfn(function(){});
   // Patch successful.
-  assertIteratorResult("Capybara", true, iter.next());
+  assertPromiseValue("Capybara", promise);
 
-  // Patching will fail however when a live iterator is suspended.
-  iter = generator(function(){});
-  assertIteratorResult(undefined, false, iter.next());
-  assertThrows(function() { patch(generator, "'Capybara'", "'Tapir'") },
+  // Patching will fail however when an async function is suspended.
+  var resolve;
+  promise = asyncfn(function(){return new Promise(function(r){resolve = r})});
+  assertThrows(function() { patch(asyncfn, "'Capybara'", "'Tapir'") },
                LiveEdit.Failure);
-  assertIteratorResult("Capybara", true, iter.next());
+  resolve();
+  assertPromiseValue("Capybara", promise);
 
-  // Try to patch functions with activations inside and outside generator
+  // Try to patch functions with activations inside and outside async
   // function activations.  We should succeed in the former case, but not in the
   // latter.
   var fun_outside = MakeFunction();
@@ -104,16 +115,18 @@ function patch(fun, from, to) {
       return;
     }
     fun_patch_attempted = true;
-    // Patching outside a generator activation must fail.
+    // Patching outside an async function activation must fail.
     assertThrows(function() { patch(fun_outside, "'Cat'", "'Cobra'") },

[caitp (gmail), 2016/06/08 14:01:24]

New theory on why this is broken:

By the time we get here, we have lots of unclosed generators on the heap, but
none actually on the stack (since V8 does not keep track of async stacks
itself)... So there isn't really a way to know if this should throw or not,
theres no recoded relationship between the async call, the inside call, or the
outside call.

I'm not sure how we'd make this work, tbh, at least not on the V8 side

                  LiveEdit.Failure);
-    // Patching inside a generator activation may succeed.
+    // Patching inside an async function activation may succeed.
     patch(fun_inside, "'Cat'", "'Koala'");
   }
-  iter = generator(function() { return fun_inside(attempt_fun_patches) });
+  promise = asyncfn(function() { return fun_inside(attempt_fun_patches) });
   assertEquals('Cat',
                fun_outside(function () {
-                 assertIteratorResult('Koala', false, iter.next());
+                 assertPromiseValue('Koala', promise);
                  assertTrue(fun_patch_restarted);
                }));
 })();
+
+%RunMicrotasks();